Comparison Chart
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moonlight Luxury Dreamer Crib Mattress with Dual Surfaces | One of the best baby toddler crib mattresses in the market, Moonlight Luxury Dreamer Crib, provides premium and quality crib mattresses to little ones and moms around the world. | ||
| Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress | One of the highest-rated and best baby toddler crib mattresses in this list, the Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress, is not just an excellent baby mattress as it is also affordable. | ||
| Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed | A highly-rated and Amazon’s choice, this mattress from Newton Wovenaire is the most hygienic mattress in this list and is recommended by experts. | ||
| Milliard Premium Memory Foam | This highly-rated and best baby toddler crib mattress from Milliard presents you with so many extras at a very low price. | ||
| Eco Classica III 2-Stage Baby & Toddler Mattress by Colgate Mattress | Also rated as Amazon’s Choice, this baby and toddler mattress from Colgate Mattress is backed by extensive research for comfort and safety use of babies and toddlers. | ||
| Sealy Baby Firm Rest Antibacterial Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress | Another highly-rated and best baby toddler crib mattress, the Sealy Crib Mattress has an anti-sag design to provide your baby with optimal support. | ||
| Dream On Me, Holly 3” Fiber Portable Crib Mattress | Weighing only three pounds, this highly-rated Dream On Me is our favorite mattress for travel cribs. |
A Detailed Review on the 7 Best Baby Toddler Crib Mattresses
Moonlight Luxury Dreamer Crib Mattress with Dual Surfaces
One of the best baby toddler crib mattresses in the market, Moonlight Luxury Dreamer Crib, provides premium and quality crib mattresses to little ones and moms around the world.
Product Highlights
This mattress features an easy to clean and waterproof fabric. The fabric is also made with a cool gel memory foam, medical-grade, stretch-knit encasement, and is odor-resistant. The mattress is also two-sided. One side is extra-firm, which is excellent for newborns. After a certain age, you can flip the mattress over for a softer feel that will be excellent for your toddler. It can help your baby sleep easily with its flexible and high-performing fabric encasement that allows the mattress to support all touchpoints of their bodies.
The Good
Moms love that the mattress is water-resistant and stain-resistant, so it won’t easily get damaged when you accidentally spill things on it. You can use a damp sponge or fabric without any cleaning products to clean the mattress. It is made of two layers of foam, encased with a waterproof, and stretch-knit polyester that remains intact. This mattress also has a medical-grade material that features an antimicrobial coating.
The Bad
Some moms reported that the toddler side is too firm. Others also noted that the center of one side of the mattress started sinking after only a few months of use.
PROs
- It has an antimicrobial feature
- Has Anti-odor control
- Features dual design
- High-quality fabric
- SafeSewn seams
- Water-resistant and stain-resistant
- Easy to clean
- Quality tested
CONs
- The toddler side is too firm
- Center of the other side started sinking after a few months
- It doesn’t fit on a standard crib size
Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress
One of the highest-rated and best baby toddler crib mattresses in this list, the Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress, is not just an excellent baby mattress as it is also affordable.
Product Highlights
This premium and highly-rated foam mattress from Graco has an exceptional value. Instead of a memory foam that’s used in most adult foam mattresses, this one adopts polyurethane foam for your baby’s safety. It fits all standard cribs as well as toddler beds.
The Good
Moms really like the washable cover that comes with this mattress. Plus, it’s made with 100% polyester and removable cover. It’s easy to wash either by hand or machine and does a great job guarding the foam mattress underneath. The mattress is also breathable, maximizes airflow, and also stain-resistant.
The Bad
Some moms and users reported that if the baby crib mattress is not opened within two weeks upon purchase, it may not fully expand. Also, others noted that it’s quite pricey than others.
PROs
- It has amazing value
- Comes in a convenient and lightweight box
- Made with polyurethane foam that provides excellent support and Airflow for infant’s safety
- Removable cover makes cleaning easy
- Breathable mattress
- It is stain-resistant
CONs
- If the baby crib mattress is not opened within two weeks upon purchase, it may not fully expand
- It’s quite pricey compared to others
Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
A highly-rated and Amazon’s choice, this mattress from Newton Wovenaire is the most hygienic mattress in this list and is recommended by experts.
Product Highlights
This crib mattress by Newton Wovenaire crib mattress comes with a machine-washable removable cover that is easy to clean. There are spaces in the matter that allows airflow through it. The design guarantees that your baby can breathe through the fabric. This is the reason why it’s recommend by pediatricians. It also promotes proper temperature regulation, so that your baby won’t feel too hot or too cold.
The Good
The mattress is very comfortable for your baby. It has a unique blend of materials. You just have to make sure not to use hot water or apply extreme heat to the mattress as it will undoubtedly shrink. This also means that you should only tumble dry the mattress itself. Wash it using cold water and then hang it to dry. It is GREENGUARD as well as CPSC certified.
The Bad
Some moms noted that some of the mattresses are too hard. Others also reported a strong plastic smell.
PROs
- Removable machine washable cover
- Has 3D cloud design
- Cover is tumble-dyer safe
- You can wash the whole mattress
- It has extra breathable feature
- 100% recyclable
- It is hypoallergenic
- It has Waterproof cover
- Lightweight design
CONs
- Mattress is too firm for a toddler
- There is also a strong scent of plastic present
Milliard Premium Memory Foam
This highly-rated and best baby toddler crib mattress from Milliard presents you with so many extras at a very low price.
Product Highlights
The Milliard crib mattress gives your baby a comfortable and affordable luxury experience. Designed with comfort in mind, the bed features a unique airflow to adjust your child’s temperature. The mattress cover is made from bamboo and is machine washable and waterproof so you can simply remove & wash the cover. Its memory foam is made with a three-pound construction that will not bottom out over time, letting your young one use and enjoy this mattress as long as they fit on it.
The Good
Moms love it’s dual-use that makes it suitable for babies and then toddlers. If you’re looking for an affordable one, it’s even suitable for young children. It’s waterproof, and the cover is removable and can be machine-washed. It is also certified non-toxic.
The Bad
Although this mattress is highly-rated, some moms fear that the memory foam is a potential safety hazard to kids. Plus, the cover also got holes after several washes.
PROs
- Removable cover is easy to clean
- High-quality brand and fabric
- It is hypoallergenic
- Dual-use for babies and toddlers
- Anti-crease cover
- It is noise-free
- It is comfortable
- It has value for money
- Waterproof cover
- Foam base ensures firm surface for babies
CONs
- The memory foam is a potential safety hazard
- The mattress cover has holes after washing several times
Eco Classica III 2-Stage Baby & Toddler Mattress by Colgate Mattress
Also rated as Amazon’s Choice, this baby and toddler mattress from Colgate Mattress is backed by extensive research for comfort and safety use of babies and toddlers.
Product Highlights
The Colgate Eco Classica provides babies and toddlers an orthopedic style mattress experience. It’s dual-use indicates your child can use it as they grow. Turn the mattress over to the softer side for toddler use. It’s high-quality and a breathable organic mattress, and the foam is infused with plant oils making it safe chemical-free. The certified organic waterproof cover will keep your baby dry & warm. It’s also GREENGUARD Gold certified.
The Good
Moms love that it’s lightweight, and the sheets are easy to change. The foam is also made with non-food plant oils, so it’s safe for babies. The mattress has a six inches thickness, firm, and hypoallergenic. Plus, it’s water-resistant and easy to clean.
The Bad
While this mattress seems to be a favorite by many, some moms reported about the poor stitching of the mattress cover. Others also complained that the mattress cover couldn’t be removed or cleaned separately.
PROs
- Easy to change sheets
- Organic and GREENGUARD Gold certified
- It has dual-design
- It has a sleek design
- Organic cotton cover
- Safe eco foam
- It is easy to clean
- No chemical smell
- It is water-resistant
CONs
- Mattress cover can’t be removed or cleaned separately
- Poor stitching on the mattress cover
Sealy Baby Firm Rest Antibacterial Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress
Another highly-rated and best baby toddler crib mattress, the Sealy Crib Mattress has an anti-sag design to provide your baby with optimal support.
Product Highlights
This Sealy baby firm rest gives optimal orthopedic support that has a 204-high coil system mattress. It offers a safe space for your child while giving maximum comfort. The coils also provide a firm surface for the child to rest on. The mattress has hospital-standard materials and is excellent to help prevent illnesses. It also offers an awesome lifetime warranty.
The Good
Moms love that the mattress is lightweight and waterproof. You can use a damp cloth to clean it. Do not use harsh chemicals as it will damage it, and the mattress will absorb them. The stiffness of the mattress makes it perfect for infants as they rest. It also a hypoallergenic cushion, which adds to the comfort of the child. This is undoubtedly like a luxurious mattress for any little king or queen.
The Bad
Some moms noticed that the mattress gives out noise when the baby moves around. Other moms also wished that there were different baby colors.
PROs
- It belongs to quality brand
- Easy to clean
- It is hypoallergenic
- It is antibacterial
- It is waterproof
- Firm yet comfortable
CONs
- Quite noisy when baby moves around
- No other color option
Dream On Me, Holly 3” Fiber Portable Crib Mattress
Weighing only three pounds, this highly-rated Dream On Me is our favorite mattress for travel cribs.
Product Highlights
For moms needing a lightweight baby mattress on the go, this 3 Mini from Dream On Me is the best choice. It only weighs three pounds and is the perfect mattress to pair with your portable crib. Although it weighs practically nothing, this 3” thick baby mattress provides excellent support for your baby. It is also made in the USA with high-quality materials.
The Good
Moms love that the vinyl cover is durable and is very useful if you’re traveling a lot as it easy to clean. It is also stain-resistant, so it shouldn’t get dirty easily. Just wipe it with a cloth, warm water, and mild soap. It’s non-toxic and is Greenguard certified. The mattress also promotes good airflow for babies.
The Bad
Because of its size, it’s only fit for infants and shouldn’t be used as a permanent baby mattress at home. Plus, the vinyl cover can also be very noisy.
PROs
- Only weighs three pounds
- Fits any brand of mini travel cribs
- Easy to clean vinyl cover
- Stain-resistant
- It is non-toxic
- Made in the USA
- Promotes good airflow
CONs
- Size only fit for infants
- Noisy vinyl cover